Whether you should repair or replace a cracked toilet depends on the location and severity of the crack. Seemingly minor cracks could be dangerous in the wrong spot, and large cracks in a safer place on your toilet can be repaired.
That said, there are more considerations that you might want to take into account. Keep reading to learn more about this topic and how you can make the best decision for your home.
The Severity & Location of the Crack Matter
Cracks in toilets can appear in various places, each affecting the functionality and safety of the toilet differently. Hairline cracks in the bowl or tank may seem minor but can worsen over time, leading to leaks or complete breakage. Cracks in the base or around the bolts can compromise the toilet's stability, posing a risk of tipping or leaking.
Hairline Cracks in the Bowl or Tank
Hairline cracks often occur due to the natural wear and tear of the porcelain. While they may not immediately cause leaks, they can weaken the structure. Over time, the pressure from daily use and water expansion can cause these cracks to grow, potentially resulting in leaks or even a shattered toilet.
You could repair a hairline crack on the bowl or tank as a temporary measure, but you should also prepare to replace the toilet in the future.
Cracks in the Base or Around Bolts
Cracks in the base or around the bolts can be more severe. These cracks can lead to water seepage, damaging your bathroom floor and subfloor. They also affect the toilet's stability, creating a hazard, especially for children or elderly individuals who might rely on the toilet for support.
For these reasons, it’s generally not advised to repair the toilet and instead replace it.
Assessing the Age & Condition of the Toilet
The age of your toilet plays a significant role in the decision-making process. Older toilets, especially those over 15-20 years old, might not be worth repairing due to their outdated technology and inefficiency. Modern toilets offer better water-saving features and improved flushing mechanisms, making them more environmentally friendly and cost-effective in the long run.
Advantages of Modern Toilets
Newer models provide several advantages over their older counterparts. They use less water per flush, which can significantly reduce your water bills. Many modern toilets also come with advanced features like dual-flush options, self-cleaning mechanisms, and improved comfort designs. Investing in a new toilet can enhance your bathroom experience and contribute to water conservation efforts.
Weighing Repair Costs Against Replacement
Repairing a cracked toilet can be a temporary solution, especially if the crack is minor and in a non-critical area. However, repeated repairs can add up, both in terms of time and money. Consider the costs of repair parts and labor against the price of a new toilet. Sometimes, replacing the toilet can be a more cost-effective and long-term solution.
Contact Us for a Professional Opinion
If you want a professional opinion on whether to repair or replace your cracked toilet, you can always turn to Meyers Companies, Inc. for help. Not only can you benefit from our years of experience and vast knowledge when it comes to toilets, but we can also provide the plumbing services you need when you make the decision that’s right for your home.
Send us a message today to learn more about how Meyers Companies, Inc. can help.